Two months after Haggai’s first message, on the twenty-first day of the seventh month, the word of the Lord comes to him again. The temple work has begun, and the people have gathered at the site for the Festival of Tabernacles, a joyous feast. The younger generation, the ones who came back from exile and have never known anything else, are happy simply to have built something with their own hands. But Ezra records something else happening in the same crowd. The older generation, the few who were there when they last saw Solomon’s temple standing in its full glory, are weeping. To them, this new structure looks like almost nothing. God addresses their grief directly.
Who of you is left who saw this house in its former glory? How does it look to you now? Does it not seem to you like nothing?
Haggai 2:3 (NIV)
Why does the outward appearance of the temple matter more to people than God speaking to them again?
For sixteen years, God had been silent toward this returned, distracted people. Now He is speaking again, walking with them, present in their camp the way He always had been. And yet what consumes the older generation is not that He has returned to speak but that the building does not measure up to what their memory has kept polished and gleaming. Without a personal, living experience of God, people default to whatever their ancestors handed down, the gold plating, the grandeur, the ritual. They chase the outward form because it is the only thing they can actually measure.
Outward Transformations over Inward Renewal
We do the very same thing today. Think of how a sermon delivered honestly and plainly, without the rise and fall of a rehearsed cadence, without the swelling music underneath it, does not feel like a “real” sermon to some ears. We want the old forms because the old forms feel safe, even when they were never really the point. There is a pattern running through all of scripture worth noticing here: God keeps allowing these grand structures to fall, because every time people gather together, they start planning a temple, a tower, a Babel of their own, something visible they can point to and call devotion. And whenever that structure succeeds without actually drawing people closer to Him, that success itself becomes the danger.
But now be strong, Zerubbabel, declares the Lord. Be strong, Joshua son of Jozadak, the high priest. Be strong, all you people of the land, declares the Lord, and work. For I am with you, declares the Lord Almighty. This is what I covenanted with you when you came out of Egypt. And my Spirit remains among you. Do not fear.
Haggai 2:4-5 (NIV)
They did not need a temple that could rival Solomon’s for God’s Spirit to be present among them. His presence was never tied to the grandeur in the first place; it was tied to His covenant, made long before any temple existed at all.
Why do we still equate a grand building with God’s presence?
We have all walked into a grand cathedral or a large, well-appointed church and felt an unspoken certainty that God must be especially near to us in a place like this. Some of that is simply how we are shaped from childhood, absorbing the idea that bigger is better. Some of it is a quieter equation we have built in our own minds between cost and devotion: the more expensive the offering, the harder it was to build, the more it must prove our love. That is why so many temples across so many religions sit on the tops of hills, difficult to reach, costly to construct, as if difficulty itself were the currency of sincerity. People will empty their savings for a gold or silver cross to mark a church anniversary, and yet the same generosity rarely appears when the need in front of them is simply feeding people who are hungry. We are, without quite admitting it, honoring the materials more than the God they are meant to represent, the very mistake David named when he said he was living in a fine house of cedar while the ark of God sat in a tent.
The glory of this present house will be greater than the glory of the former house, says the Lord Almighty. And in this place I will grant peace, declares the Lord Almighty.
Haggai 2:9 (NIV)
This temple, built by people who were essentially still subjects of a foreign empire, could never rival what the wealthiest king in Israel’s history once built. And yet God says its glory will be greater, because what would eventually be granted there was not gold or silver, but peace, the peace that would arrive centuries later in the form of His Son. The people standing there that day had no way to grasp what they were being promised. And it raises a fair question for us too: do we understand it any better now, having actually received it? Or do we still default to the same substitute peace they were chasing, the assumed peace of wealth and security, imagining that once we reach a certain target we will finally feel settled?
That assumed peace is exactly what blocks people from discovering the real one. Only when we stop chasing gold and silver as the source of our security do we start to have room for a peace that actually surpasses understanding, one that does not simply numb our desires of the world but removes the desires altogether. And that, honestly, is why so few people want it. A drug that takes away your appetite for something you love is not a popular drug, even when it is free. People are not ready to let go of the desire for wealth, or the desire to sin, even to receive something greater in exchange. We keep pushing that peace for a later point in our life till we have had our fill with the riches that the world has to offer.
Consecrated & Defiled
Three months later, on the twenty-fourth day of the ninth month, God speaks to Haggai again, and this time He turns to the priests with a question about the law.
If someone carries consecrated meat in the fold of their garment, and that fold touches some bread or stew, some wine, olive oil or other food, does it become consecrated? The priests answered, “No.” Then Haggai said, “If a person defiled by contact with a dead body touches one of these things, does it become defiled?” “Yes,” the priests replied, “it becomes defiled.”
Haggai 2:12-13 (NIV)
Consecration does not transfer by contact, but defilement does. It is a simple ruling the priests already understood, and Haggai uses it to make a much larger point: whatever these people bring, whatever they offer, is defiled, because they themselves are defiled underneath. The priests knew the law well enough to answer correctly, and still, like most of us, they kept operating on a different, unstated assumption, that giving something, tithing, fasting, volunteering, some visible sacrifice, could somehow offset what was wrong in them. We do the same thing today, worrying less about the debt Jesus already settled on the cross than about this week’s specific failures, the lie we told, the money we should not have taken, the thing we are ashamed of, and rather than confessing it honestly, we quietly try to pay it down ourselves through some other good deed.
Where do we get the confidence that our sacrifices can make us clean?
This confidence comes from the same place all our worldly transactions come from: the assumption that doing something earns a result, that effort converts a negative into a positive, that the outcome is in our hands if we simply work hard enough. We carry that logic straight into our relationship with God. Jesus taught us to pray that His will be done on earth as it is in heaven, not to negotiate a trade of goods and services. But it is far easier to hand someone money than to hand God our heart, and that gap is exactly what gets exploited. People who present themselves as operating on God’s behalf, rather than simply being used by Him, can make it seem as though spiritual power itself is for sale, that enough giving buys enough peace, enough forgiveness, enough assurance. The demand for that exchange exists in us before any supplier shows up to meet it; we are the ones carrying the guilt and the money, looking for somewhere to unload both at once. Remarkably, God does not ask anything further of them in return.
Now give careful thought to this from this day on… From this day on I will bless you.
Haggai 2:15,19 (NIV)
He marks the exact date as a visible sign, a restoration point they can look back to and remember. Unlike every other voice offering them a formula, God asks for nothing in exchange for this blessing. He simply tells them to believe, and to remember the day.
A Sign for the Rest of Us
On that same day, God speaks to Haggai a second time, this time about Zerubbabel personally.
On that day, declares the Lord Almighty, I will take you, my servant Zerubbabel son of Shealtiel, declares the Lord, and I will make you like my signet ring, for I have chosen you, declares the Lord Almighty.
Haggai 2:23 (NIV)
We do not actually know what became of Zerubbabel after this. What we do know is what he represented, a link in the line of David, a placeholder for the promise of an everlasting kingdom that would eventually be fulfilled. God has a similar plan for us, drawing us into that same lineage, making us sons and daughters of Abraham, sending His own Son to die for us so that we could be joined to that kingdom rather than merely observing it from outside.
How are we distracted from that plan the way the returning exiles were distracted by their paneled houses?
Our version of the paneled house is rarely as obvious as an actual mansion or a home loan, though sometimes it is exactly that. More often, it is whatever feels urgent in the moment, because almost anything can feel more urgent than God, who, by comparison, never seems to be in a hurry. And the more subtle danger is not the things we know we are doing wrong. It is the things we think are bringing us closer to Him and are not: staying busy building something for His kingdom, a project, a cause, a role in the church that uses our particular talents, that keeps us comfortable, that never asks us to actually leave where we already are.
We can spend twenty years convinced we are walking toward God while quietly walking in place, or even away from Him, replacing an actual relationship with the appearance of service. There is also a temptation to treat scripture as what one of us called a magic mirror, a mirror that reflects everyone else’s faults rather than our own, applying every hard word to a pastor, a sibling, a friend, and never quite to ourselves. But the word of God was never meant to work that way. It examines the heart it is read into first. Let us not be like the people in Haggai’s time focused on our outward appearances of righteous but look to Christ and be renewed each day.
Reply